Home » Uncategorised » Under/Over Development in Film Photography

Under/Over Development in Film Photography

Spread the love

It’s something we all accidentally do when we develop our films, or, we do it for a reason. I don’t purposely Over or Under develop my films unless I am pushing or pulling in which case I will allow compensation in camera. I always try to hit the correct development times for my exposures in camera.

I decided to experiment and see what happens for my own eyes if I over developed for 2 minutes and under developed for 2 minutes.

For this I used Silberra 54UN 100 speed film. Which is basically ORWO UN54 100 film! But enough of rebrands. In fact, I love this film and if it wasn’t for me grabbing a roll of Silberra 54UN a few years back I would never have discovered ORWO. So thanks Silberra! Great rebrand and public awareness.

I took a simple scene in my darkroom consisting of a Buddha and a Camera. I has whites, blacks and mids in the scene and I burst it with hard LED light.

I took three photographs using the Olympus OM20 and developed each negative in separate film canisters all at the simultaneously.

I used Ilford ID-11 at 1:1 20°. The rated time for this film at that dilution was 7 minutes. But as I wanted to develop one film over and one under I set my timer for 9 minutes.

IGNORE THE TIME ON THE CLOCK. THAT WAS ANOTHER FILM MY FIRST TEST WHICH WENT WRONG)

After 5 minutes, in complete darkness, I puled canister 1 out and then stop and fixed it. I did the same for canister 2 but at 7 Minutes (correct time) and canister 3 at 9 minutes.

I made a contact print and then made 5×7 enlargements.

For the enlargements I took the correctly developed negative, made a test strip and then made my print, which was 2 seconds under the enlarger. I then took the other two negatives and did exactly the same for the same time. There was no point in making individual test strips for each negative. I needed to see the difference.

Here are the final results taken from a DSLR of the original prints. You can make your own conclusions.

As for the Under and Over negs I could have easily got my tones back with some filters under the enlarger and maybe some dodging and burning. Especially the over developed print. I feel that would have ended up being punchy.

Latest YouTube Video

Download the NEW SFLaB ebook on Compositions
Download the SFLaB Beginners guide to Film and Darkroom
SFLaB FILM MERCH
Join me and others on Patreon
Buy me a Coffee or Film